Donor conception the Irish way…and yet another comment on known donation

Back in the saddle following nearly two weeks in France and good to get my head back into the donor conception world with our visit to Dublin to talk with counsellors in the newly formed Irish Fertility Counsellors Association.  It is always a pleasure to go to Ireland. There is something about Irish people that makes me feel warm and welcomed and I just love Irish voices…even the hard and broad Dublin accent, which my more refined Irish friends make terrible fun of.  The group of women (and one man) we met with on Saturday were delightful as, in my experience, most counsellors are.   Donor conception is in it’s infancy in Ireland and they had provided us with a list of questions and issues they wanted to discuss.  Because of a lack of legislation and regulations surrounding donor conception which makes it impossible to protect donors or recipients in the way that the HFE Act does in the UK, no donors are recruited within the country.  Sperm is imported from Denmark and most people requiring egg donation are referred to clinics in Spain, although certainly in the recent past embryos created in the Ukraine with sperm from the recipient’s partner and an anonymous Ukrainian egg donor, have been implanted in Irish clinics.   The issues that arise for couples and single women are very similar to those of UK residents but with an added edge of the stigma that has largely dropped away in most of the UK now.  The counsellors felt that the climate about ‘telling’ the child was changing significantly towards openness but that very many people were very anxious about what others would say and about how the child would be treated at school.  Also, because all donors are anonymous, a common and often aggressively posed question from would be and actual parents is about the wisdom of telling a child s/he is donor conceived when there is no further information that can be given.

So often the answers to these complex questions comes down to basic beliefs and values.  If you value integrity and honesty in relationships then telling your child as much information as you have about their donor – whether it is a lot or a little – is clearly going to be the right thing to do.  If parents are confident and comfortable about their decisions then they will be able to be proud and open about their child’s beginnings and celebrate the culture, ethnicity and country of their donor and the clinic where they conceived.  If they secretly feel ashamed and stigmatised by the use of donor conception then they are unlikely to want to share information with the child or anyone else about this different way of creating a family.  A counsellors’ sometimes very difficult role is to explore these feelings and tease out what is really going on.

Walter and I were impressed with this group and hope to keep in touch with them in the future.  Hopefully, we will be going to Cork later in the year to talk with would-be and current parents of donor conceived children, an event that the counsellor in the clinic there has long been wanting to organise.

And to finish, just a comment on the story in the Sunday Times today on yet another known donor scenario that went disastrously wrong, this time involving the now defunct Man Not Included agency.  It involved a man donating sperm, with the apparent agreement of his wife, to a lesbian couple who, because of fertility problems, needed to use a surrogate mother who self-inseminated with the donor’s sperm.  Problems arose when the wife of the donor had feelings about the baby and indeed about the putative relationship of her husband to the surrogate and broke down weeping at a dinner party.  The whole story is enormously complex but seems to have been resolved satisfactorily (at least as far as the adults are concerned as the children are still small) but the donor admitted that he had entered into the arrangement very naively, with complete disregard for the law and without taking into account the possibility that his wife’s feelings might change.

The bottom line is that known donor arrangements MUST involve counsellors, lawyers and most of all protracted periods of talking and listening on the part of all parties over a long period of time before an agreement of understandings and expectations is drawn up. And most important of all, the needs of the child should be at the heart of the matter.


About oliviasview

Co-founder and now Practice Consultant at Donor Conception Network. Mother to two donor conceived adults and a son conceived without help in my first marriage.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Donor conception the Irish way…and yet another comment on known donation

  1. busymum7 says:

    Couldn’t agree more about the need to go into known donor arrangements very carefully – when they work well within the HFEA guidelines and with full counselling of all involved parties, the results can be outstandingly positive but this story sadly shows that without these safeguards in place, things are not always straightforward. Let’s hope that the resolved situation above stays resolved.

    • marilynn says:

      But is it not possible for people’s feelings to change once their offspring are born, regardless of whether or not they were counseled and felt comfortable about not raising their offspring initially when the offspring were only abstract ideas rather than actual people that are related to them no different than a child they might have conceived with a spouse or significant other? Counseling might alert them to the possibility of these feelings in the future and by way of that stop some people from going forward with donating gametes. But the reason they don’t enforce pre-birth contracts to give children up for adoption is because the person is not yet a parent, their offspring does not exist and they are not in a position to relinquish their obligations to their offspring. Its hard for me to see the difference, since in the end, if their offspring are born it is then that the terms of any agreements come into play.

Comments are closed.